The Difference Between Tawassul and Major Shirk: Understanding the Position of Some Hanbali Scholars
Question: السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته شيخ، حياك الله وأحسن الله إليك I heard that some of the major Hanabila scholars allowed Tawassul with the righteous; they quoted Imam Hajjawi in his Iqna, ibn al-Najjar in his Muntaha al-Iradaat, ibn Muflih in his Kitāb al-Furu’ and so on. My question is that is this not shirk? Or did the earlier scholars have a different definition for Tawassul جزاك الله خيرا شيخ والسلام عليكم
Summary:
Tawassul through the righteous, their status, or their persons was not regarded as major shirk by the majority of the scholars who permitted it or were lenient regarding it (This is because they were speaking about asking Allah alone, not calling upon the dead or seeking aid from them). Rather, they considered it to be among the issues of tawassul over which there is scholarly disagreement. Therefore, the early Imams whose names you mentioned were not referring to calling upon the dead, seeking aid from them, or directing worship to anyone besides Allah. As for major shirk, it is to call upon a deceased person or someone absent, seek rescue from them, or ask them to fulfill needs and relieve hardships. This is what the texts came to prohibit and clarify as being shirk.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
First: It Is Necessary to Distinguish Between Tawassul and Istighathah
Many misunderstandings have arisen due to a failure to distinguish between these two matters.
- Tawassul is when a servant supplicates to Allah alone, but places a means before his supplication.
For example, he says:
"O Allah, I ask You by Your Most Beautiful Names."
"O Allah, I ask You by my faith in You."
"O Allah, I ask You through the supplication of Your righteous servant."
In all of these cases, the One being asked and supplicated to is Allah alone.
As for seeking aid from the dead or calling upon them, such as saying:
"O so-and-so, help me."
"Heal my sick relative."
"Fulfill my need."
This is supplication directed to other than Allah and is considered major shirk according to Ahl al-Sunnah.
Second: What Did the Hanbali Scholars Mean When They Permitted Tawassul?
The statements found in some Hanbali works, such as al-Iqnaʿ, Muntaha al-Iradat, and al-Furuʿ, generally refer to:
Tawassul through the Prophet ﷺ, his status, or his right when making supplication.
In other words, the supplicant calls upon Allah alone and does not call upon the Prophet ﷺ. For this reason, those scholars did not understand this practice to be shirk; otherwise, they would not have permitted it.
Third: What Is the Position of the Verifying Scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah?
A number of the verifying scholars, such as Ibn Taymiyyah, Muhammad ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab, and those who came after them from the scholars of the Salafi daʿwah, held that:
- The legislated form of tawassul is tawassul through Allah’s Names and Attributes.
- Or through righteous deeds.
- Or through the supplication of a living righteous person.
- As for tawassul through status, right, or person, they held that it is not legislated because there is no evidence establishing it.
- Nevertheless, they distinguished between innovation and major shirk.
- Thus, tawassul through the status of the Prophet ﷺ is, according to them, an innovation or an unlegislated means, but it is not major shirk so long as the supplicant calls upon Allah alone and does not direct worship to other than Him.
Fourth: Why Did the Early Scholars Not Declare Those Who Practiced It to Be Disbelievers?
Because they did not intend by it the supplication of anyone besides Allah.
If merely saying:
"O Allah, I ask You by the status of Your Prophet"
were major shirk, then it would necessitate declaring entire groups of jurists from the four schools of law to be disbelievers, since they discussed and permitted this issue.
This was never the position of the Imams of Ahl al-Sunnah.
For this reason, the scholars differentiated between:
- Innovated tawassul.
- Major shirk.
Not every innovation constitutes major shirk.
Final Answer:
- The early scholars who permitted certain forms of tawassul did not intend calling upon the dead or seeking aid from them.
- The tawassul mentioned in their books consists of asking Allah alone while mentioning the status of a Prophet, a righteous person, or similar matters.
- The majority of those who permitted this type of tawassul did not regard it as shirk; rather, they considered it a form of tawassul.
- Verifying scholars from Ahl al-Sunnah, such as Ibn Taymiyyah, held that the legislated tawassul is only that which is established by evidence, and that tawassul through status or person is not legislated.
- Major shirk is calling upon other than Allah, seeking aid from other than Him, or directing acts of worship to other than Him, not the mere tawassul over which scholars differed.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to QuestionsRelated Answers
Asking a Living Person in a Form That Resembles Du‘ā’
Clarify a matter for me. Du‘ā’ is an act of worship, but my question is: if a person asks a living person for something he is able to do, such as asking his father to bring him a shoe, then he says to his father, I supplicate you that you bring me the shoe, is this considered shirk? I know that asking a living person who is able for something that he is capable of is not shirk, but my question is: what if he asked him in the form of du‘ā’, while he is capable of doing it? I want to understand what is meant by “du‘ā’” that is worship.
Clarifying the Issue of Excusing Ignorance in Major Shirk
Contradictory opinions on the "Excuse of Ignorance" in kufr Shaykh Şälih al-Fawzän said: So the one who save "I do not declare takfir on these, 1 do not declare takfir on those who worship al-Hasan and al-Husayn and al-Badawi; I do not declare them kafir because they say:لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّٰهُ, they are our brothers, but they made a mistake" we say to him: You are a mushrik like them, because you did not disbelieve in what is worshipped dbesides Allaah. What he is trying to say. And Sheikh Uthymeen Shaykh al-Uthaymeen Rahimullah who very clearly affirms the excuse of ignorance. What is the correct opinion, I am confused. What is the correct opinion. I am terrified becz of Sheikh Fawzan saying. What he actually trying to say? Personally I take sheikh Uthymeen view . Am I correct or wrong , I am just a layman
Are All Sufis Misguided?
Are all types of Sufis bad? Is every Sufi an innovator?