Is It Permissible To Study Non-Aqeedah Books Written By Ashari Scholars?

Question: السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Can we study books not related to Aqeedah by asharis like al itqab uloom al Quran as suyuti? And generally speaking, can we learn from asharis if it is not Aqeedah? And can we study Aqeedah from them to refute them?

Summary:

It is permissible to benefit from the books of the Asharis and other people of innovation in fields that are unrelated to their innovation, such as Arabic language, Tafsir, Qiraat, Hadith, Usul al Fiqh, and similar sciences, while exercising caution regarding any false interpretations or errors in Aqeedah that they may contain. However, if these sciences are available in the books of Ahlus Sunnah, then it is not permissible to abandon those books in favor of the books of the people of innovation. Rather, the books of Ahlus Sunnah must be given precedence and relied upon. As for academic universities, a student may be required to study some of these prescribed texts. In that case, he should limit himself to what is necessary while remaining firmly grounded upon the Aqeedah of Ahlus Sunnah and being cautious of doubts. As for attending the public lessons or gatherings of the people of innovation in the mosques, this is not permissible because they may mix truth with falsehood, introduce doubts under the guise of truth, distort the words from their proper places, and thereby deceive those who cannot distinguish between the Sunnah and innovation. As for their books on Aqeedah, they should only be read by those who possess knowledge and insight, and only for the purpose of refuting them and exposing their doubts. A beginner, or anyone who fears being affected by their doubts, must not expose himself to them.

Answer:

First: The Principle of Accepting the Truth and Rejecting Falsehood

From the Qur'an:

  • [Surah At Tawbah : 119]
    "O you who have believed, fear Allah and be with those who are truthful."
  • [Surah Az Zumar : 17–18]
    "So give good tidings to My servants, those who listen to the word and follow the best of it."

The Prophet ﷺ said: "Wisdom is the lost property of the believer; wherever he finds it, he has more right to it." This Hadith was graded weak by Al Albani. Although this Hadith is not authentically attributed to the Prophet ﷺ, its meaning is correct. A believer continually seeks the truth and is eager for it, and nothing prevents him from accepting it wherever it becomes apparent. Therefore, whoever speaks correctly or speaks the truth, his statement is accepted. The criterion is agreement with the evidence, not merely the name of the author. Second: Is It Permissible to Study Ashari Books in Subjects Other Than Aqeedah? Yes. It is permissible to study the books of the Asharis and other people of innovation in matters unrelated to Aqeedah when there is a need, provided that the following conditions are fulfilled: -There must not be a book by Ahlus Sunnah that sufficiently covers that field. If such a book exists, then it is not permissible to abandon it in favor of the books of the people of innovation. -The student must genuinely need to study them, such as when they are prescribed in a university or academic program that cannot be avoided. -The instructor should be Salafi in Aqeedah, clarifying the truth rather than teaching the author's methodology. -The instructor should warn against the deviations and corrupt principles of the Asharis and point out their errors whenever they arise. -The reader or student should be well grounded in Aqeedah or study under the supervision of someone who can distinguish truth from falsehood for him so that doubts do not become attached to him. -He should limit himself to what is necessary and not expand his reading of the books of the people of innovation when suitable alternatives from Ahlus Sunnah are available. -The study should not become a means of honoring the people of innovation or promoting their books. Rather, it should only be for benefiting from knowledge unrelated to their innovation while rejecting their falsehood. These conditions summarize the statements of the scholars regarding this issue. The fundamental principle is that the books of Ahlus Sunnah are to be given precedence, and one should only resort to the books of the people of innovation when there is a need, while being safe from temptation and remaining cautious of their falsehood. For example: Al Itqan fi Ulum al Quran by As Suyuti is a beneficial work in the sciences of the Quran, and scholars have benefited from it, while noting the errors it contains in some matters of Aqeedah or in the transmission of certain reports. For this reason, the scholars said: The truth is accepted from whoever brings it, and his falsehood is rejected. Third: Is It Permissible to Learn Other Sciences From the People of Innovation? If the teaching concerns something unrelated to their innovation, there is a genuine need for it, and it does not affect one's Aqeedah, then there is no harm, subject to the conditions mentioned previously.

From the Scholars:

  • Shaykh Ibn Uthaymin رحمه الله was asked about studying under people of innovation in subjects other than the Islamic sciences, and he replied:
    "There is nothing wrong with that... However, if you see him calling people to his innovation, then you must report him... And the student is compelled to attend in the regular schools."

Fourth: Is It Permissible to Read Their Books on Aqeedah in Order to Refute Them? This is permissible only for the people of knowledge who possess insight and sound understanding. As for others, it is not.

From the Scholars:

  • Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله said:
    "Whoever has the ability and hopes that Allah will benefit others through him may read them and refute them... But if his knowledge is limited and he fears being affected by them, then he should not read them. However, if he has knowledge, insight, and is able to refute them and expose their doubts, then this is part of striving in the cause of Allah."
  • He also said:
    "Reviewing the works of the people of innovation... if a scholar reviews them in order to refute them and clarify their falsehood from their own books, then there is no harm."
  • He likewise said regarding reading the books of the People of the Book, which is a general principle applicable here:
    "No one should examine them except the people of knowledge and insight when there is a need to refute them."

Fifth: What Is the Position of Ahlus Sunnah Regarding the Books of the Asharis? Ahlus Sunnah have explained that the books of the people of innovation are not all the same. If they contain correct knowledge unrelated to their innovation, then one may benefit from it while remaining cautious. If they deal with Aqeedah or promote innovation, then they should only be read by those qualified to refute them. For this reason, the Imams of Ahlus Sunnah would sometimes quote from those who differed with them in fields such as Arabic language, history, and Hadith, while refuting whatever errors they made in matters of Aqeedah. Conclusion: The basic principle is that the books of Ahlus Sunnah are to be given precedence, and it is not permissible to abandon them in favor of the books of the Asharis or other people of innovation when suitable books of Ahlus Sunnah are available. However, if there is a need to study some of their books in subjects unrelated to Aqeedah, then this is permissible to the extent of that need, provided the Islamic conditions are met. These include sound Aqeedah, the presence of a Salafi instructor who clarifies the author's errors and warns against them, safety from temptation and doubts, and limiting such study to genuine necessity rather than expanding it or taking knowledge directly from the people of innovation. As for attending their public lessons or gatherings, this is not permissible because of the danger of spreading doubts and mixing truth with falsehood.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions

Related Answers

Do We Blame Abu al-Hasan al-Ash’ari for His (Aqeedah) Creed?

Do we blame Abu al-Hasan al-Ash’ari for his creed?

Read full answer

Methodology and Preconditions for Studying the Six Books of Hadith

What are the prerequisites for a student of knowledge to begin studying the six books of Hadith and other works such as al-Muwaṭṭaʾ? Does he need to reach a certain level in the science of Hadith, grammar, morphology, principles of jurisprudence, and other sciences before studying these books?

Read full answer

Advice for Young Muslims Seeking Islamic Knowledge While Pursuing College and Business?

What advice would you give to a young man who is sixteen years old, striving to seek Islamic knowledge and memorize the Qur’an, while at the same time studying in college and considering work or business?

Read full answer

Can a Student of Knowledge Benefit from the Books of Authors Who Have Errors in Creed or Methodology?

What are the guidelines for a student of knowledge regarding benefiting from a book whose author has errors in aqidah or methodology, especially in books of fiqh? Is it a condition that we only take knowledge from those who are clearly upon the methodology of the Salaf, or is it permissible to benefit from such works with caution and certain guidelines? An example is Ibn Rushd and his book Bidayat al-Mujtahid, which is a famous book that is taught and widely benefited from.

Read full answer

Is It Recommended to Study Islamic Knowledge Through Books Independently, or Only by Listening to Scholars?

As-salāmu ʿalaykum wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh, Shaykh. I wanted to ask regarding seeking knowledge. Do you only recommend that students study by listening to scholars and their lessons, such as on YouTube, or is it also fine to read books like Kitāb al-Tawḥīd with the explanation of Shaykh ʿAbd al-Raḥmān al-Saʿdī or al-ʿAqīdah al-Wāsiṭiyyah with the explanation of Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah on my own? If reading them independently is acceptable, are there any conditions or advice you would give? Jazākum Allāhu khayran.

Read full answer