Am I Required to Repay My Two Friends After We Jointly Lent $600 to Another Friend Who Is Unable or Refuses to Repay the Debt?

Question: Our Honorable Sheikh, We 3 friends used to live together. 1 of the friend needed money to borrow 600$ and I paid him 600$, and wrote in the message in our friends group chat that I've paid the friend 600$, and we can divide the debt for us 3 people so it will be easy on myself. That means the 2nd and 3rd friend paid me $400. Now the 1st friend who took 600$ is unable or refusing to pay back. The 2nd and 3rd friend are saying since we paid you the money 200$ each, you should pay us back, not the 1st friend. Please guide me since I became the gurantor in the middle, do I have to pay back the 2nd and 3rd friend. I wrote in the group chat that he will pay back everyone's money.

Summary:

The basic principle is that the debt of $600 remains the responsibility of the friend who borrowed the money. The person who initially lent him the money is not obligated to return the amounts paid by the other two friends if they contributed those amounts as participation in the loan, and all parties agreed that each of the three lenders would have a claim of $200 against the borrower. However, if the two friends paid the $400 as a loan to the questioner himself, or if the agreement stipulated that he would guarantee repayment to them, then he is obligated to return the money to them. What matters is the actual nature of the agreement between the parties, not merely the fact that the questioner was the one who received the money from them. It is not permissible for the borrower to delay repayment of the debt when he is capable of paying it. However, if he is genuinely experiencing financial hardship, he must be granted respite until his circumstances improve.

Answer:

First: Evidence from the Noble Quran

From the Qur'an:

  • [Surah al-Maidah: 1]
    "O you who have believed, fulfill [all] contracts."
  • [Surah an-Nisa: 58]
    "Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due."
  • [Surah al-Baqarah: 280]
    "And if someone is in hardship, then [let there be] postponement until [a time of] ease."

    These verses indicate the obligation of fulfilling lawful contracts and agreements, returning rights to their rightful owners, and granting respite to a debtor experiencing financial hardship.

Second: Evidence from the Sunnah of The Prophet ﷺ

From the Sunnah:

  • Narrated by al-Bukhari and Muslim.Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه narrated that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
    "Delay in payment by a wealthy person is injustice."
  • Narrated by al-Bukhari.Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه narrated that the Prophet ﷺ said:
    "Whoever takes people's wealth intending to repay it, Allah will repay it on his behalf; and whoever takes it intending to destroy it, Allah will destroy him."

    These two Hadiths indicate the obligation of repaying debts and the prohibition of delaying repayment when one is capable of paying.

Third: Statements of the Scholars

From the Scholars:

  • Imam Ibn Qudamah رحمه الله:
    "The agent is entrusted, and he is not liable for what is lost while in his possession without negligence, whether he acts for compensation or without compensation, because he acts on behalf of the owner and is therefore similar to the person entrusted with a deposit." [Al-Kafi]

    This indicates that a person who handles money as an agent on behalf of its owners is not liable for it unless he transgresses or is negligent.

  • Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen رحمه الله:
    "The correct view is that all those entrusted with property are not liable except in cases of transgression or negligence." [Sharh al-Kafi]
  • Regarding the rulings on suretyship and financial guarantees:
    The jurists have established that when a guarantor undertakes to guarantee another person's debt, he may be required to repay the debt according to the conditions of the guarantee. The original borrower is not released from liability merely because a guarantor exists.

    However, merely acting as an intermediary between the lender and borrower does not establish financial liability.

Fourth: Applying the Ruling to the Questioner's Situation: The questioner mentioned that he lent his friend $600, then asked the other two friends to participate in the loan. Each of them paid $200, and he explicitly stated in the group chat that the borrower would repay everyone's money. If the two friends agreed to this arrangement, then the basic principle is that the debt is distributed among them as follows: Person entitled to payment: The questioner Amount Owed: $200 dollars Person entitled to payment: The second friend Amount Owed: $200 dollars Person entitled to payment: The third friend Amount Owed: $200 dollars Total amount: $600 In this case, the borrower is responsible for repaying each of them their respective amounts, and the questioner is not liable for guaranteeing the shares of the other two friends merely because he received the money from them. As for the questioner's statement, "I have become like a guarantor or surety," this statement alone does not establish a guarantee under Islamic law. This is because suretyship is a financial obligation that must be established through a valid agreement or undertaking, not merely through a feeling of responsibility toward others. However, it is important to note that the two friends paid their money after the questioner had already lent the full amount to the borrower. Therefore, it is necessary to verify whether they lawfully acquired shares in the original loan, or whether their payments constituted an agreed-upon settlement for participation in the lending arrangement, rather than a new loan made to the questioner himself. What matters is the actual nature of the transaction, not merely describing it as a partnership. If it is established that they personally lent money to the questioner, then he is obligated to repay them, even if the original borrower does not repay his debt. Fifth: The Ruling on the Borrower's Refusal to Repay: If the borrower is capable of repaying the debt but refuses to do so, then he is committing injustice and sin, because the Prophet ﷺ said: "Delay in payment by a wealthy person is injustice." However, if the borrower is genuinely experiencing financial hardship, he must be granted respite until his circumstances improve, because Allah, the Most High, says: "And if someone is in hardship, then [let there be] postponement until [a time of] ease." [Surah al-Baqarah: 280] Conclusion: The stronger opinion is that the questioner is not obligated to return the $400 to the two friends if it is established that their agreement was to participate in the loan, that the original borrower was responsible for repaying everyone's shares, that the questioner did not undertake to guarantee their repayment, and that no transgression or negligence occurred on his part. However, if the two amounts were loans made to the questioner himself, or if it is established that he guaranteed repayment of the debt, then he is obligated to fulfill whatever financial liability has been established against him. Resolving this matter depends on reviewing the exact wording of the written message, the agreement of the two friends to its terms, and determining the true nature of the transaction that took place after the original loan was given. If a dispute arises regarding these matters, it is necessary to refer to a competent Islamic authority to examine the agreement and the evidence.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions

Related Answers

Participating in Bank Promotions and Interest-Based Offers

I recently opened a student checking account with an American Bank for a debit card. After completing 10 qualifying transactions (worth $100), they offer a one-time $100 promotional bonus/gift for opening an account with them. Is it halal to use the money acquired from this?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible to Use Postpaid Mobile Service if the Contract Contains a Late Payment Penalty Clause?

Peace be upon you, and the mercy of Allah and His blessings. I live in Canada and I use a postpaid mobile service. The plan does not include the device itself, but only the SIM card and services (data, calls, and texts). I pay a fixed monthly fee, which is automatically withdrawn from my bank account on the due date. However, the service provider’s terms include a late payment penalty if the payment is not made on time. But I always pay on time, and the automatic withdrawal ensures that I never delay. My question is: Is it permissible (ḥalāl) to use this postpaid service, knowing that the contract contains a late payment clause, even though I never intend to delay?

Read full answer

Does Debt Reduce the Amount of Zakah That Must Be Paid?

The questioner asks, He has a debt estimated at about fifteen thousand eight hundred dollars. This amount was taken from one of his relatives. When the money was given, no specific date for repayment was agreed upon. Rather, the owner of the money may request it at any time, perhaps tomorrow, or after several months, or at a later time. So what is the correct way to calculate zakāh in this situation? Should he deduct this debt from the total amount in his bank account first, then pay zakāh on the remaining amount? Or should he pay zakāh on the full amount that he owns without deducting the debt?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible to Sign a Student Loan Agreement That Includes Interest Penalties For Late Repayment?

Can a student sign a contract that stipulates interest on a loan if the student doesn’t pay back their loan on time? They can avoid it if they do indeed payback on time, but interest applies if they are late. This works like a credit card; if you payback the amount you borrowed on time, no interest applies. Thank you.

Read full answer

What Is The Ruling On Donating Unintentionally Received Interest?

I unintentionally recieved interest from the bank through some kind of saving account, After realizing this i dont want to gain any benefit from this money. Can i donate the amount to needy people or to my siblings or parents. Is that permissible?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible to Pay a Registration Fee for an Interest-Free Tuition Payment Plan?

At my university, we can enroll in a tuition installment plan that is free of any interest. However, when enrolling in the plan, we are required to pay a $30 registration fee. Is this fee considered riba, or is it simply an administrative fee that is permissible?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible to Take a New Interest-Based Loan to Repay Existing Interest-Based Debts When No Alternative Is Available?

Assalam Alaikum. I would like to ask for guidance. I am currently burdened by interest-based (riba) debts from several lending providers. The total amount owed now exceeds my monthly salary, and I am constantly facing threats and intimidation. I am at a loss as to what to do. I truly wish to repent, but I have received an offer for a bank loan that could cover my existing debts, with monthly installments amounting to less than 40% of my salary. Is it permissible for me to take this bank loan to pay off the other debts—given that I have no other choice (I have no assets left to sell, no one—such as friends or family—who can lend me a sufficient amount, and I still need to provide for my children)? On one hand, I want to stop and repent from engaging in *riba*.

Read full answer