Burial Membership Programs and Cooperative Funeral Cost Coverage
Question: What is the Islamic ruling on a burial membership program in which a person pays a one-time fee of $100 as the primary member, and everyone who lives in the same household pays $20 per person as additional members? When any member of the group dies, the cost of the burial is divided among all members, and each member pays his share. Coverage also does not begin until three months after the date of membership. Is this type of system permissible in Islam?
Summary:
This system is permissible in Islam if: It is pure cooperation for covering burial costs, Without any profit-seeking party, With no investment of the funds by the organizers, The membership fees are only for administration, The burial cost is divided among the members when a death occurs, And the three-month condition is for benefit and organization. If any of these conditions are violated, the system becomes prohibited commercial insurance.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)
This type of system is called in fiqh:
A social cooperative system for covering burial costs, and it differs from the prohibited commercial insurance if it adheres to Islamic conditions and regulations.
Let us present the issue according to its foundational principles:
1. The legislation of cooperation upon righteousness
From the Qur'an:
- Surah Al Maidah - 2
And cooperate upon righteousness and piety.”
This system intends cooperation in covering a Muslim’s need at the time of death, and this is among the greatest forms of righteousness. Among this is the ḥadīth of the Prophet ﷺ regarding the blood-money borne by the ʿāqilah (the man’s male relatives) in cases of accidental killing this is a financial cooperation that is legislatively binding. Scholars used this as evidence for the permissibility of cooperative systems that are not intended for profit. 2. The legislation of mutual cooperation (takaful) The Companions used to cooperate in guarantees, ʿaqalah, and blood-money, without any profitable return, which is from the door of cooperation, not commercial exchange.
Second: When is this system permissible? It is permissible under two essential conditions: Condition 1: That it not contain prohibited gharar (uncertainty) Prohibited gharar appears in commercial insurance because a person pays money in exchange for a possible commitment from the company (it may happen or may not). This is a contract of exchange. But in this system: The members cooperate in covering burial costs. The amounts are paid when a death occurs and the total is divided among all. There is no party profiting from people’s payments—the money goes to the benefit of the deceased. This is closer to donations than to commercial exchange, so it is not considered prohibited gharar. Condition 2: That there be no profit or investment of the money If those who run the program: take no profit, do not invest the money for their own interests, and their role is limited to organization and coordination, paying costs from what members contribute, then it is cooperative and permissible. But if they take a fixed profit or a percentage of the funds, or invest the money for themselves, then it becomes prohibited commercial insurance. Third: What is the ruling on the upfront fees? 1. Registration fees ($100 and $20) If they are administrative fees for expenses (organization, communication, paperwork, records, staff) and not a price for coverage or a fee guaranteeing burial, then there is no harm in them, because they are payment for an actual service. 2. Paying one’s share when a member dies This is the basis of the cooperative system and is permissible, because people share in covering a need when it occurs. Fourth: What is the ruling on the three-month waiting period before coverage begins? This condition is permissible if its purpose is: preventing manipulation (someone joining while near death just to benefit), and organizing the cooperative system. The jurists have ruled that time-based restrictions in donations and cooperative arrangements are permissible when needed. Fifth: Statements of the Scholars 1. The Council of Senior Scholars They distinguished between commercial insurance (prohibited) and cooperative/takaful insurance (permissible) if based on donations and cooperation, not commercial exchange or profit. 2. The Permanent Committee (al-Lajnah al-Dā’imah) They permitted cooperative systems when there is no profit or exploitation and when they are based on mutual support and donation. 3. The International Islamic Fiqh Academy They affirmed that cooperative insurance that is based on: donation, sharing of loss and gain, absence of a profiting party, is permissible. The system in question fully matches this model if it fulfills the mentioned conditions.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions