A Mosque in London Established ʿIsha Before the Published Time: What Is the Correct Ruling?

Question: السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته. Sheikh, I was recently in a masjid in London and the prayer time in the masjid for Isha prayer was 10:40PM. My mosque stood up and started praying at 10:30PM (10 minutes before the starting time of isha prayer). After the prayer ended, i asked a few general people from the followers about this and someone mentioned that they do this often here because they believe that the isha time is inaccurate and if it was truly accurate, we would be praying at 12Am so he said its allowed to pray isha early and that the religion is easy. What is the correct stance on this and should i continue praying at this mosque? Jazakallah khair.

Summary:

If the time for ʿIsha has definitely not entered, and the prayer is performed before its time begins, then the prayer is invalid, because the entrance of the prayer time is a condition for the validity of the prayer by the consensus of the Muslims. However, if the disagreement concerns ʿIsha timetables and the calculation of twilight in countries where the day is long and the night is short, then this is a well-known matter of scholarly ijtihad among scholars and fiqh councils. A prayer is not deemed invalid merely because a mosque follows a different timetable. Therefore, it is first necessary to determine whether they actually prayed before the legislated time, or merely before the time announced by that particular mosque.

Answer:

In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.

First: The Entrance of the Prayer Time Is a Condition for the Validity of the Prayer

From the Qur'an:

  • [Surat al-Nisaʾ 4:103]
    “Indeed, prayer has been decreed upon the believers at prescribed times.”

From the Sunnah:

  • The Prophet ﷺ also saidwhen explaining the prayer times:
    “The time is between these two.”

The scholars unanimously agreed that whoever performs an obligatory prayer before its time begins, while knowing and remembering, then his prayer is invalid.

From the Scholars:

  • Ibn al-Mundhir رحمه الله said:
    “The scholars unanimously agreed that whoever performs a prayer before its time must repeat it.”

Therefore, it is not permissible to say, “The religion is easy,” as a justification for performing the prayer before its proper time, because legislated ease is not attained through contradicting the revealed texts. Second: What Is the Reality of the Issue in London and Similar Places? In many areas of London and other northern European countries, there is a well-known disagreement regarding the determination of the time of ʿIsha during certain seasons of the year. This is because the legislated sign for the beginning of ʿIsha is the disappearance of twilight, and in some regions this occurs very late or becomes difficult for people to determine. For this reason, some mosques and Islamic centers have adopted different methods of calculation. You may find one mosque setting ʿIsha at 10:30 PM, another at 10:45 PM, another at 11:15 PM, and another even later. Therefore, a difference of ten minutes alone is not sufficient to conclude that they prayed before the legislated time. Third: When Is the Prayer Invalid? • If it is established with certainty that the mosque is praying before the legislated prayer time according to the very timetable it follows, or according to the recognized legislated signs, then the prayer is invalid. • However, if the matter is based upon a recognized scholarly ijtihad regarding the calculation of prayer times, then this is a different issue. • A disagreement regarding timetables is not the same as knowingly praying before the prayer time. Fourth: What Should You Do? Ask the imam of the mosque or the mosque administration: • Which timetable do you follow? • Why is the published time 10:40 PM while the prayer is established at 10:30 PM? • Is 10:40 PM the adhan time or the iqamah time? • Was the schedule changed without updating the announcement? There may be a simple explanation for the matter. As for relying upon the statements of some members of the congregation, this is not sufficient to conclude that the prayer is invalid. Final Answer: • Praying ʿIsha before its legislated time is invalid according to the consensus of the scholars. • It is not permissible to use the principle that “the religion is easy” as a justification for praying before the prayer time begins. • In places such as London, there are recognized scholarly positions regarding the calculation of the time of ʿIsha, so a prayer is not deemed invalid merely because of differing timetables. • One must verify the reality of the matter by asking the imam of the mosque or those responsible for it. • If it becomes clear that they deliberately establish the ʿIsha prayer before its legislated time with certainty, then do not pray that prayer with them until the time enters. However, if the matter is based upon a recognized scholarly ijtihad regarding the determination of the prayer time, then there is no harm in praying with them.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions