Laughing During Sujūd al-Sahw After the Salām

Question: If a person performs Sujud al-Sahw after giving the salām from prayer, then laughs, what must he do?

Summary:

Summary Sujud al-Sahw after the salām is part of the prayer in ruling. Laughing during it invalidates the prayer because it is laughing inside an act of prayer. He must repeat the prayer completely. If it was only smiling without sound, then the prayer is valid according to the majority.

Answer:

First: The basis of the issue

Laughing in the prayer invalidates the prayer by consensus of the jurists, because it contradicts khushu and is considered play.

But the place of consensus is laughter inside the prayer.

As for if the laughter occurs after the salām, and the praying person is performing Sujud al-Sahw after the salām, this is the issue being asked about.

Second: Is Sujud al-Sahw after the salām considered part of the prayer?

Yes, Sujud al-Sahw that is done after the salām is still connected to the prayer, and it is from its completions, not from the outside remembrances.

From the Sunnah:

  • Sahih al-Bukhari 1227Abu Huraira
    The Prophet (ﷺ) led us in the `Asr or the Zuhr prayer and finished it with Taslim. Dhul-Yadain said to him, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! Has the prayer been reduced?" The Prophet (ﷺ) asked his companions in the affirmative. So Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) I offered two more rak`at and then performed two prostrations (of Sahu). Sa`d said, "I saw that 'Urwa bin Az-Zubair had offered two rak`at in the Maghrib prayer and finished it with Taslim. He then talked (and when he was informed about it) he completed the rest of his prayer and performed two prostrations, and said, 'The Prophet (ﷺ) prayed like this.' "

    This shows that the prostration after the salām is an obligatory act to complete the prayer, and that it remains under the ruling of the prayer.

Third: The ruling of laughing during Sujud al-Sahw after the salām

The Hanafis, Shafiis, and Hanbalis They clarified that Sujud al-Sahw after the salām is part of the prayer in ruling, and that laughing during it invalidates the entire prayer, because the completions of the prayer carry the same ruling as the prayer.

From the Scholars:

  • Al-Nawawi said,
    “Sujud al-Sahw when it is after the salām is part of the prayer in ruling.”

From the Scholars:

  • Ibn Qudamah said,
    “Whoever laughs in Sujud al-Sahw, his prayer becomes invalid because it is from the parts of the prayer.”

The Malikis They consider laughter invalidating for the prayer as well, whether inside it or in Sujud al-Sahw, because it is connected to it. The scholars are agreed that laughing in Sujud al-Sahw invalidates the prayer. Fourth: What must he do? He must: Repeat the entire prayer again. Because Sujud al-Sahw is part of the prayer, and laughter invalidates the prayer, so when the prostration becomes invalid, what is connected to it becomes invalid, which is the prayer itself. This is the stronger view according to the majority. Fifth: Does the ruling change based on the type of laughter? Yes: Smiling without sound: This does not invalidate the prayer according to the majority of scholars, but it contradicts khushu and is a deficiency, and the prayer remains valid. Laughing with sound: This is what invalidates the prayer without any significant disagreement. So if what came from him was only smiling without sound, then his prayer is valid and he completes Sujud al-Sahw. But if it was laughter with sound, he must repeat the prayer.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions